conferences
 
Sea of Inhumanity
Tibet in the Great Proletarian Cultural Revolution
Dharamshala, October 29 & 30, 1996
 
Literature for Freedom
First National Conference of Tibetan Writers
Dharamshala, March 15 to 17, 1995
 
 


 

  Sea of Inhumanity
 
  Tibet in the Great Proletarian Cultural Revolution  
 
  Dharamshala, October 29 & 30, 1996
Department of Information and International Relations, Dharamsala, India
 
 
  Next to the invasion and occupation of Tibet by Red China, the Cultural Revolution was undoubtedly the greatest catastrophe to afflict Tibetan society this century. It swept through the lives of the Tibetan people with the violence of a major war, the chaotic destruction of a cyclone or an earthquake, and the horror, suffering and madness of a medieval pestilence. Yet there has been little study of the Cultural Revolution in Tibet, or any reasoned evaluation of its impact on Tibetan society and history. In China retrospection on the Cultural Revolution has not met with official disapproval and has, consequently, seen discussion not only in academia, but in literature, art and film.

What we know of the effects of the Cultural Revolution in Tibet is largely confined to the physical destruction of monasteries, temples, images and reliquary. Little is known of its psychological impact on Tibetan society, or the changes wrought in the everyday life and thinking of ordinary people. Little has also been studied of the actual power play behind the Cultural Revolution in Tibet, and the personalities who rose and fell because of the events.

One of the least examined, and hence, least known consequences of the Cultural Revolution and the factional fighting in Tibet is the growth of a national consciousness among Tibetans which resulted in violent uprisings all over Tibet around 1967-1969, and which the Chinese in Tibet dubbed the "Second Tibetan Rebellion".

On the 30th anniversary of the Cultural Revolution, AMI held this conference "Tibet in the Great Proletarian Cultural Revolution". Fourteen papers were presented, and ten more papers have been submitted for inclusion in the forthcoming proceedings.

AMI dedicated this seminar to the memory of those countless Tibetans who suffered and perished in the holocaust of the Cultural Revolution.

 
  The Programme
 
   October 29, 1996
 
  Opening Session
Moderator: Jamyang Norbu

Offering of butter-lamp and prayer for the memory of those Tibetans who died during the Cultural Revolution.
Nechung Monastery

Why we need to look back and to understand the Cultural Revolution.
Mr. Jamyang Norbu

The Origins of the Cultural Revolution in Tibet
Mr. Tsering Wangchuk

Second Session
Moderator: Ven. Jampa Tenzin

The power struggle of destruction and suffering: my experiences of the Cultural Revolution in Drapchi prison
Kasur Shewo Lobsang Dhargyay

The experiences of one family in Lhasa during the Cultural Revolution
Mrs. Tsering Dolkar

Third Session
Moderator: Mr. Tsegyam

An account of the crimes committed during the Cultural Revolution in the Golok area
Ven. Damchoe Palzang

An account of how the various programmes of the Cultural Revolution were implemented in Dzachukha, Kham
Mr. Jamyang Ludrup

Fourth Session
Moderator: Prof. Jampa Gyaltsen Drakthon

An eyewitness account of the Cultural Revolution in Labrang, Amdo
Kalön Alak Tsayü Tenzin Palbar

An account of the Cultural Revolution in one village in Lhokha district
Mrs. Dhondup Choedon

 
   October 30, 1996
 
  Fifth Session
Moderator: Kalön Sonam Topgyal

The main objectives of the Cultural Revolution and the Cultural Revolution in Gonjo, Kham
Mr. Tsenam

A brief account of the Cultural Revolution in Khyungpo Tengchen, Kham, and the "1969 Rebellion"
Mr. Jampa Sonam

Sixth Session
Moderator: Kasur Shewo Lobsang Dhargyay

Background to the Red Guard fractional fighting in Lhasa
Mr. Tsering Wangchuk

The royal family of Mewu (Ngaba, Amdo) and the Cultural Revolution. Retrospection of the Princess of Mewu
Mrs. Mewu Gompo Tso

Seventh Session
Moderator: Mr. Kunsang Paljor

The experiences of the wife of the late Tibetan Government official, Tsipön Namseling during the Cultural Revolution
Mrs. Choekyi Namseling

A review of the Tibetan novel on the Cultural Revolution, "Vultures in the Black Whirlwind", by Chime Dorjee, People's Publishing House of TAR, 1995
Prof. Jampa Gyaltsen Drakthon

Eighth Session
Moderator: Mr. Tashi Tsering

Transcripts of telephone conversations of Chinese leaders in Tibet and China during the Cultural Revolution obtained from a secret wiretapping operation in Kongpo area in 1969
Kasur Lhamo Tsering

(See also Kasur Lhamo Tsering's book published by AMI, "Resistance, vol.1 and 2".)

 
   

 
 

  Literature for Freedom
 
  First National Conference of Tibetan Writers  
 
  March 15 to 17, 1995
Bhagsu Hotel, McLeod Ganj, India
 
 
  His Holiness the Dalai Lama inaugurated the Conference on the morning of the 15th and spent about an hour with the delegates. In His message he mentioned that this conference would have a strong and positive impact on the development of Tibetan literature. His Holiness remarked that inside Tibet, even more than literature, the very language - Tibetan words and names - was disappearing. It was therefore vital that Tibetans living in a free country should make every effort to protect Tibetan literature. On a more immediate level the Dalai Lama talked of how necessary it was for Tibetan writing to modernize, and the need for a consistent phonetic system to render all foreign and scientific terms into Tibetan. He also stressed the need to bridge the gap between the language as used by the scholars and that of the lay people.

Sixty-two delegates from various parts of India, Nepal, Switzerland, U.K. and USA took part in the Conference. Due to limitations of space, only eighteen observers could attend.

 
  Messages
   
  Besides a message from His Holiness the Dalai Lama, the conference received messages from H.H. Sakya Trizin; Dzarong Trulshik Shatrul Rinpoche; Dr. Samten G. Karmay, CNRS, Paris; Prof. Samdong Rinpoche, Principal, Centre for Higher Tibetan Studies, Varanasi; the Kashag; the Assembly of Tibetan Peoples Deputies; the Department of Religion & Culture and the Department of Education.

Of particular encouragement to the organisers and delegates were two messages from outside the Tibetan community. The first was from the headquarters of International PEN (World Association of Writers), London:

"We send you our warmest wishes for the success of this, your first meeting, which is to be inaugurated by His Holiness the Dalai Lama. As an international organization of writers which fights for endangered languages, as well as for our persecuted colleagues, we have a particular interest in the preservation of the Tibetan language and literature, as well as a particular sympathy for Tibetan writers."

The second was from Czeslaw Milosz, winner of the Nobel Prize for Literature, 1980, who wrote:

"Please receive my words of solidarity and sympathy. I lived a long time in exile and I understand your problems and your hopes. You have friends in many countries of the world, and you should be convinced that what you write in solitude and isolation will one day be known and remembered with gratitude."

   
  Participants
   
 

Aside from scholar-writers like Dhongthog Rinpoche from Seattle and Rakra Rinpoche (the oldest delegate at 71) from Switzerland, many younger writers (the youngest, Lhagon Kyap 21) living in exile and also recently arrived from Tibet, participated as well. Many editors of cultural/literary journals and newspapers in exile also participated. Elderly lamas mingled and deliberated freely with younger writers. Everyone seemed to enjoy each other's company. Academics and writers from Ladakh and Lahaul, and a Nepalese editor of a Tibetan language paper, added to the variety in peoples and opinions. Many of the younger writers expressed their great satisfaction in being able to meet, many for the first time, older better-known writers living faraway or abroad, and discuss their works with them. A number of the senior writers also expressed their pleasure in being able to meet so many younger writers and were encouraged by their zeal and their ability.

One of the participants, Palden Gyal, a poet now living in London, remarked in an interview that though he was enjoying the event, his feelings were somehow mingled with sadness at the thought of his poet friends back home in Amdo, who could not attend this first-ever gathering of poets and writers. (See also Palden Gyal's book published by AMI, "The Offering and Other Poems".)

Ven. Thupstan Paldan, a robust middle aged monk from Ladakh (J&K Academy of Art, Culture and Language, Leh) impressed the interviewer with his prolificacy. Not only had he produced many short stories (his latest collecion has just been released) but also a number of radio-plays, which had been broadcast on All India Radio. Thupstan Paldan, like many others, praised the efficient organization and atmosphere of the Conference and the high standard of papers and discussions. Ladakh's own tremendous efforts to preserve its literature and culture would certainly gain from these deliberations, Thupstan Paldan added

   
  Gedun Choephel Award
   
  The Gedun Choephel Award is to be presented by AMI every three years to an outstanding Tibetan writer who has maintained dedication and courage in the face of persecution and hardship. The Award carries a cash prize, and a specially framed citation.

His Holiness the Dalai Lama received the First Gedun Choephel Award for his writings, especially for "My Land and My People". All delegates were allowed one vote and were requested to submit their nominations in sealed envelopes at the time of registration. The Dalai Lama was the clear winner having received a majority of the votes. His Holiness thanked the conference for the prize but felt that the participants should reconsider their decision as it could probably set a wrong precedent of important lamas getting the Award, thus depriving ordinary hard-working writers the chance of winning it. His Holiness in all modesty also declared that he did not really consider himself a literary person but rather a religious pracitioner. His Holiness' request was discussed and it was decided that since the Dalai Lama had already received a majority of the votes cast by the delegates and was further indisputably deserving of the Award, there was no other recourse but to request His Holiness once again to accept it. His Holiness the Dalai Lama has accepted the Award. On the last day of the conference a committee of seven was eleced to select the next recipient for the Gedun Choephel Award.

   
  A Thought for Freedom
   
  In keeping with the theme of the Conference and with the hope of adding some fresh inspiration to our struggle, all participants were requested to contribute an essay, story, verse or else on the subject of "Freedom". These were collected at the end of the Conference and were published in 1995 under the title of "Voices of Freedom".
   
  The Programme
 
   March 15, 1995
 
  Opening Session

Literature vs. propaganda: the power of truth
Paper
Kalön Sonam Topgyal
Moderator: Mr. Maja Tsewang Gyurme

Evolution of Tibetan language and usage since 1959
Paper
T.G. Dhongthog Rinpoche
Moderator: Prof. K. Angrub

Second Session

New Tibetan writing, origins and features
Panel Discussion
Dr. Ringu Tulku
Ven. Lobsang Gyatso
Mr. Pema Bhum
Mr. Pema Tsering

Moderator: Kalön Kesang Yeshi

Writing for children
Panel Discussion
T.C. Rakra Rinpoche
Mr. Ngawang Dorjee
Mr. Gompo Tsering
Mr. Kalsang Khedup

Moderator: Mr. Jamphel Phuntsok
 

 
   March 16, 1995
 
  Third Session

Tibetans writing in Hindi and Sanskrit
Paper
Acharya Gyaltsen Namdöl
Moderator: Prof. K. Angrub

Foreign words, standardization of the spelling, phonetics and rendition of foreign words
Panel Discussion
Khenpo Migmar Tsering
Dhongthog Rinpoche
Acharya Karma Monlam

Moderator: Ven. Alak Tsayü Tenzin Palbar

Fourth Session

Playwriting and scriptwriting, importance of these in a semiliterate society
Panel Discussion
Prof. Drakthon Jampa Gyaltsen
Mr. Kunsang Paljor

Moderator: Mr. Jamyang Norbu

Proofreading, developing new punctuation conventions, proof correction marks, and styling for contemporary Tibetan writing
Panel Discussion
Mr. Jampa Tenzin
Mr. Tsering Wangchuk
Mr. Tshewang Tamdin

Moderator: Lhasang Tsering

Fifth Session

Gendün Chöphel: the writer as a social pioneer
Paper
T.C. Rakra Rinpoche
Moderator: Mr. Dawa Norbu

Writers and the Amnye Machen Institute
Workshop
Mr. Jamyang Norbu
Moderator: Mr. Dawa Norbu

Sixth Session

Tibetans writing in Chinese (literary)
Paper
Mr. Tsegyam
Moderator: Ven. Alak Tsayü Tenzin Palbar

Tibetans writing in Chinese (political)
Paper
Mr. Tsering Wangchuk
Moderator: Ven. Alak Tsayü Tenzin Palbar

Obligations in writing
Recognition of intellectual property, necessity of proper publication-data in books, submission of copy of every publication to the Library of Tibetan Works and Archives, etc.
Workshop
Mr. Lobsang Shastri
Moderator: Ven. Alak Tsayü Tenzin Palbar

Foreign words, standardization of the spelling, phonetics and rendition of foreign words (Part 2)
Panel Discussion
Khenpo Migmar Tsering
Dhongthog Rinpoche
Acharya Karma Monlam

Moderator: Ven. Alak Tsayü Tenzin Palbar

 
   March 17, 1995
 
  Seventh Session

The social and political limits of contemporary Tibetan literature
Paper
Pema Bhum
Moderator: Acharya Gyaltsen Namdol

Survey of Tibetan women's writings
Paper
Tashi Tsering
Moderator: Prof. Drakthon Jampa Gyaltsen

Eighth Session

Colloquialism, advantages and disadvantages
Panel Discussion
T.C. Rakra Rinpoche
Dr. Ringu Tulku
Prof. K. Angrub
Moderator: Dhongthog Rinpoche

Tibetan PEN Centre
To introduce the PEN Charter and the idea of forming a Tibetan PEN centre. It is hoped that membership in PEN will provide some minimal protecion to persecuted Tibetan writers in Tibet, and also help Tibetan writers to view their profession and ideals in a more global context.
Workshop
Lhasang Tsering
Moderator: Dhongthog Rinpoche

Ninth Session

Computers and the Tibetan script
The need for standardization of Tibetan computer codes, programmes, keyboards etc.
Workshop
Mr. Phuntsok Namgyal
Mr. Christophe Besuchet